We love Nicole and think she's hilarious in this video! Our Simon Cowell. If you have a problem with her being "too mean" please direct that towards US as constructive criticism on how we edit. Any attacks on her as a person are simply uncalled for and we will not tolerate any personal hate towards the incredible and talented experts we bring into our fold. Remember, this is all just fun and games. As the people forced to eat this food every week we can promise you her comments were justified and spot-on 😂

Pumkin Spice

Måned siden

She was hired to judge and she did just that.

Natasha Mazumdar

Måned siden

Lol what I think she's fucking hysterical.

Ashley Joyes

2 måneder siden

I love her!!

Emerald cumberland

2 måneder siden

​@Katelyn I think Nicole Rucker made the comedy even greater and more theatrical. She has a name, btw.

RACHEL CurtisB

2 måneder siden

I honestly thought the vide was great, my only critique when it comes to the editing around Nicole was just a touch overpowering. I honestly feel like she it became a lot for apparent because she was paired with two more neutral judges. The part where she flat out disagrees with one the other judges off the bat HILARIOUS, amazing, that was some stellar editing! I feel like if Nicole had been paired with someone like Roe who has a hard time giving harsher critique, that would be a great dynamic! And her comments would have a better balance. That all being said I do hope Nicole comes back next season! But I think pairing her with someone to match her energy(just in the opposite direction) would help balance the criticism. And make her comments still hilarious, but help keep it fun and jokey.

Ned is Jesse Tyler Ferguson! They are doppelgangers!

Tell Ned, Crawfish man, it is Peeeeea CAN, not Pea Con. ;)

Love kitchen battle ...

"What is milk? Its cow water....basically the same shit." -Zach 2020

You should do some episodes where you make different national cuisines - as a Brit I would suggest Yorkshire puddings (I’m also from Yorkshire;), pork pies, sausage rolls, fish and chips, scones, Victoria sponge, steak bakes etc etc 💞

Idk what ppl are talking about, I thought Nicole was hilarious. She critiqued and like joked with the guys but was a good sport when they joked around with her too

i genuinely don't know how you guys had a problem with nicole? i found her critique hilarious. she took it so seriously and that's what made it funny.

12:09 best and most satisfying moment of the episode

i'm probably alone in this but i honestly don't think that that one judge was insanely harsh like others are saying.

I think we know what that one judge is going to say when he gets home.

Mythical josh and binging with babish

Its funny that Keith keeps doing the raisin things even after not winning last season. But do you dude. I would be curious to try Eugenes and Zachs cheesecakes. Neds looks like the cheesecake you buy at a restaurant so good job.

Love the random cow snippets

Having read all comments I rather have honest judge then one who favor Zach that's in diy stuff. Or ones that way Eugene didn't make what tasked with but wins anyway. I really don't mind Nichole being so blunt it was judged fairly. And don't say cause I favor Keith. Because I liked dumpling episode when Eugene won because fair. If I'm not sure on fairness I'll neither like nor dislike.

Did you guys saw how Ned finished half of that bottle after getting 4th place!🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

0:14 JIMMY I watch all their game knights videos

A lot of German cheesecake recipes have raisins in them lol so Keith's combo was like "pretty basic" to me

Ok, since this is the last episode in this season I feel like I wanna say something. I absolutely love this series and for the most part enjoyed it. Over the course of the whole baking without a recipe series there have been quite a few judges that have appeared. Most of them were very polite but were still able to give important and honest feedback. On the other hand there have been a couple that have struck me as extremely rude and almost “full of themselves” to the point that the episode becomes pretty unenjoyable. I understand that this series is supposed to be where professionals critic the guys but there is a better and more appropriate way to do it. There were a couple of episodes that made me extremely upset and uncomfortable because of just how rude some of the judges were acting. There’s a difference between being rude and giving constructive criticism. I don’t know if they were caught on a bad day or if they are just a bit too uptight for my tastes. Anyway, not trying to hate on anyone, just my thoughts on it. 💕💕💕

I loved Nicole

I have yo remember that these are adults...in the best way😂😂

So no one is gonna talk about how Keith danced like Mickey Mouse from the Mickey Mouse Club House

what is happening to the closed captions why are they not in sync with the video

She’s a Judge. She’s JUDGING. What else do you want?! And not only did she judge the cheesecakes fairly (which is more than you can expect from a few judges), she also added a crazy amount of comedy into the episode. Stop complaining

FrostedCakes

5 timer siden

It's just opinion. I'm sure she's a lovely person, but there's always a reason for someone to go and comment a critique. I was uncomfortable while watching the video because of how little the guys bounced off of her. Her comedy isn't for me. That's okay in the same way it's okay that it's fun to you.

Who thinks Ned looks like Jesse Tyler Ferguson

You guys should try to make mongolian buzz

this lady was bugging me.....cheesecake is close to maybe pumpkin pie but not the same. the worst part was YES you can overmix a cheesecake. Honestly I was surprised she knew to put it in a waterbath

Keith- are you a ska kid? Bro that lil dance you did was skanking! Took me back to my ska punk kid days seeing Less Than Jake, Goldfinger, Voodoo Glow Skulls, etc, and dancing in the mosh pit!

I hope they do a reaction to these videos and see what they did wrong lol

them hiding in the corner for ned is so funny

I was listening to these video has I was napping and dreamed about the cookie version but it was in the shower, like you had to make shower cookies

Mini m+ms are better than regular. The crunch/pop sensation of eating the minis is 👌🏻 it's like the sensation you get when you bite into those big roe on some sushi. POP, but it's made of chocolate.

This and nailed it have a really great atmosphere like serious cooking shows are fun and all but I like seeing contestants and judges roast eachother it's fun! Casual+

I expected Nicole to be horrible when I read the comments but you guys... I don‘t see the problem. The guys didn‘t always bounce off of her jokes but I think she was a fine judge 💫

I don't understand why everyone was saying Nicole was rude? She was being very honest and I don't think any of her comments were rude at all. I found her sassy and absolutely hysterical.

PlanwithIvey

3 dager siden

Same! I thought she was freaking hilarious and that her and Ned’s banter was hysterical. Like this was the definition of frienemies for you 😂

I’m not attacking Nicole as a person... I just think she was a bit harsh, when the whole show is comedy. It’s not a real cooking show... I’m sure she’s a great person 💜

AriSo Fetch

Dag siden

Read the pin comment

i watched them all put solid butter in and make dough instead of Graham cracker crumble and it dealt me physic damage

I think nicole was fun. She was playing a character. Her comments made me laugh but I think the reason why a lot of ppl took it as rude is because, unlike zach, some of u didn't respond as if it was a joke which caused misinterpretation of the situation

36:14 he's right. such a Karen..

That pink Karen though.

i think the way you edited it maybe have made Nicole’s comments less enjoyable. Especially when she said “i call bullshit” to ned and his response seemed genuinely taken aback. if there was laughter to follow, it would have been much less uncomfortable.

They all went back to their roots in this episode: Ned was a true dad who just tried, Eugene used offensive amounts of alcohol, Zach was a child and Keith was *D A D D Y ‘ S F A V O R I T E*

I’m a little annoyed with the comments bc if they bring her back she might not be herself out of fear of what the comments will say. She’s good in my book

For those who are wondering who was the winner of Season 2 Without A Recipe: Keith won 2, got 2nd in 1, and got 4th in 1 Ned got 2nd in 1, got 3rd in 2, and got 4th in 1 Zach and Eugene each won 1, got 2nd in 1, got 3rd in 1, and got 4th in 1. So Keith was the winner of Season 2! Congrats!

No one, Literally no one... Me: AND I CRUNBLE COMPLETELY WHEN YOU CRY- (Haha 505)

*DOLORES* needs to get lost in a forest.

So I just watched this .. I know late to the party but I have to say we all know the reasons it is beneficial for guest judges to be on the show. You have someone who knows what they are saying to give an air of professionalism to the show and the guest judges get a free advertising for there business. However the lady in pink ( judging of the comments I have seen ) did nothing but attract negative attention to her business. She didn't shower herself in glory. She came off as that girl the needs to be the smartest in the room, that's was probably not what she was intending but never the less. I know you couldn't re-shoot at the risk of seeming disingenuous with reactions, but really what it falls down to is it was not in anyone's best interest not to pull her up after her first remarks and explain how bad this really made all of you look. This was really disappointing end to a season that you put so must work into. I hope she and the try guys learn from this to be aware of what the public may read from what you choose to post.they will probably never read this but felt like I should say something.

Imagine if the Try Guys were emotional teenagers baking a cheesecake.... Ned: Roses are red, violets are blue, my cake is trash, and I am too. Eugene: I drink alcohol because of my anxiety and wine connoisseur issues. Keith : Daddy, raising three emotions: anxiety, depression, and drunk. Zach: When I was a kid, Halloween meant trick or treat. not kick back and sleep. My parents did the second one. (I thought of commenting this down for once. Stay cool !

Just keep adding booze and rasins perfect

I love the Try Guys, and this is really fun to watch!! But I do agree that Nicole was a little too serious for Try Guys, but she might just have a problem with her tone of voice, cause I can see some of her comments as jokes, her voice just didn't quite convey it, but that happens sometimes.

These videos stress me oUT

hey i love nicole pls bring her back always

The music change from when the professional was pouring her cheesecake cut to zack 😂😂😂

I think Eugenes goal is to make the judges so drunk that their judgement is swayed

The talented price separately impress because thing significantly look behind a godly acrylic. jumpy, wild insulation

the judge in the pink shirt really just ruins the video

very good job

When 2nd place doesn’t even get recognition

Lara Lepo

4 dager siden

Lmao tru. The ending was way to snappy for a 40 minute long video

I hurt for Ned during the critique

“You didn’t have a plan” Well a plan for making food is a recipe... which kinda defeats the point of the series, justice for Ned! 😂

What i feel About the whole Nicole thing - 1. She was a bit rude (not that some others judges weren't, but her comment at the moment kind of ruined the fun part of video for me. Like I always get excited for the judgement part, coz its so funny. But this one came off as straight rude to me.... That too before I even scrolled down to see the comments. And I thought only I'm thinking like that ) 2. Some people said that their food has been called dog food before so it's not a big deal. I think dog food is still someone's food. Calling it garbage is saying that it cannot be eaten by anyone. It can be eaten. Try asking that to someone who has to sleep hungry. Another example to make you understand the difference - if your clothes are torn, and you say it's garbage, try asking the same thing to someone who doesn't get to cover themselves when it's cold outside and they don't have homes and sleep in cold like that.

The limping ladybug reassuringly memorise because year briefly repair pro a infamous network. juvenile, brief sock

do cupcakes!

I appreciate the guys pinning their request to direct negative feedback about the judging in this ep towards them not the judges so here it is... The reason i love try guys WAR over actual pro cooking shows is because its lighthearted and fun and they aren't expected to excel at it, its supposed to be funny and chill. Harsh judging makes some of us viewers anxious and nervous and usually WAR doesn't do that. I was so nervous and uncomfortable every time the camera was on that judge because while i know the guys will take the criticism in stride, to me it felt like watching a friend get told off in class by the unreasonably angry teacher we all had at some point. It took away from the reason i like WAR over pro cooking competitions. It made me too anxious and uncomfy. I do understand that she meant it as humour and i've got nothing against her at all, on a pro show she'd be the nice one! But that does nothing to calm my inner nervous child who was just terrified every time she spoke on this show because for this particular show that was so unexpected and unfortunately in a bad way... tldr; i was not expecting anything but lighthearted chill fun times because thats what WAR usually is so the negative feedback triggered me into just being anxious and uncomfortable every time that harsher judge was on camera. No hate on her tho, it just didn't work for this show.

Aisha Azeemah

7 dager siden

the most triggering bit being that she said he made excuses. It feels awful to genuinely try something outside the box only to have it shat on and then to make it worse they believe you just messed up and can't own up to that. He DID say that was his idea while he was making it. It was not just excuses.

Yikes Nicole forgot this was just fun :S

Yeah pink shirts just not the right vibe. While probably right yall have had several critical but lighthearted people before

Nicole did not passed the vibe check

Literally WHAT was that judge trying to prove? Is she trying to flirt? Are you trying to flex? It actively ruined the episode for me watching her try and neg the boys so she can seem? Superior? Christ. It’s their show. We’re here to have fun.

Gonna go ahead and say the Nicole Rucker is probably my least favourite judge that has ever been on Without a Recipe. I just found her to be irritating and not enjoyable to watch. I’m sure she’s a lovely person, but just not my slice of cheesecake.

I loved Nicole !

Idec I thought she was so fucking funny

Without a recipe idea: The Try Guys Make Pasta Without A Recipe

i don't like that nicole chick

I love Nicole she's so funny and direct

I adore the fact that Ned hides that he is a millionaire

Butter pecan icecream That sounds so ✨EXPENCIVE✨ No, seriously, the price of Pecans is up there compared to many other nuts plus they are naturally sweet so putting them in butter and then in icecream... It's mindblowing in a confusing way

"I'm disappointed before i even took a bite" has me dying

19:28 My dad the day after he gets drunk

Ok I thought Nicole was hilarious. Came across less Simon Cowell and more RuPaul for me but either way the reads were clearly in good fun. I also felt like she was bringing real technical knowledge to the table!!

The reasons why I like Asians more and more...

Wow I like "Go get them 🐯"

I am not a fan of the lady in the pink. She seems really, really condescending and rude.

Try guys make pudding without a recipe

3:12 Me sitting here eating no bake cheese cake

y'all want Gordan Fucking Ramsey but hated Nicole and honestly to me it seems like its bc Nicole's a Women

Not to be rude or anything but that girl in the pink needs to chill... I get it might be her sense of humour but it’s not even funny, it was almost rude.

kieth is so fkin funny

NGL..... lady in pink, kind of an a$$hole, not a great judge by any means, rest of the vid was great tho!

Pls have your mates try to judge

The try guys vs a family member.

Professional cook or baker vs the try. Professionals first time cooking or baking not what they know, something new. And see who would win.

Just give them the ingredients only. Not the amount of the ingredients or directions. If they add an ingredient they are on there own , for there show.

the fact u could see how uncomfortable they were when nicole spoke 😭

Try guys without a recipe ideas for next season, pasta noodles-maybe a tortellini or ravioli-a restaurant in my hometown makes a Shepard’s pie ravioli served with gravy and it’s bomb, but an idea of how creative they can get. Macaroons, or some kind of candy like candy apples, taffy. Love you guys and thank you for your amazing content, I enjoy binge watching without a recipe and have challenged myself a few times during quarantine.

Nicole tore into the poor guys

Who else was proud afff of Keith

Nicole’s judging was so refreshing, I love her energy! She’s hilarious and snappy!

Try guys should try learning a new language ^

I don’t understand what people are talking about. I love Nicole and think she’s hilarious. I’m British and maybe it just leans more into our sense of humour but she was cracking me up with her dry sarcastic comments

I love when Jimmy was talking about Eugene and Keith's cheesecakes, Ned was drinking and saying "wowww" "really?" So sarcastically